Files
OmniRoute/open-sse/services/gpt5SamplingGuard.ts
Diego Rodrigues de Sa e Souza 6cdb77a0c2 fix(openai): strip reasoning_effort when GPT-5.x models carry function tools (#7101)
* fix(openai): strip reasoning_effort when GPT-5.x tools present (port from 9router#2540)

Raw api.openai.com Chat Completions rejects GPT-5.x reasoning models that carry both function tools and an active reasoning_effort with HTTP 400 ("Function tools with reasoning_effort are not supported ... Please use /v1/responses instead"). The existing forceResponsesUpstream guard only reroutes openai-compatible-* connections carrying MCP/tool_search tool shapes; the plain openai provider had no equivalent guard, so gpt-5.x models used with a coding client (function tools + any explicit reasoning effort) still hit the upstream 400. Add stripGpt5ReasoningWhenTools() (gpt5SamplingGuard.ts), wired into chatCore.ts alongside the existing sampling guard, to drop reasoning_effort/reasoning when function tools are present and reasoning is active, letting the request succeed on /v1/chat/completions.

Reported-by: Tech Solution (@techsolutionmta) (https://github.com/decolua/9router/issues/2540)

* fix(openai): scope reasoning-strip guard to /chat/completions only

stripGpt5ReasoningWhenTools gated on provider+model-name alone, so once
#7242 routes the public GPT-5.6 family to /v1/responses (targetFormat
"openai-responses", which natively supports tools + reasoning), the two
PRs would compose into the worst of both worlds: routed to the endpoint
that supports reasoning, but reasoning stripped anyway. Pass the
request's already-resolved targetFormat into the guard and skip the
strip whenever it is not going out over /chat/completions, so the
guard tracks the actual upstream surface instead of a model-name list
that would need updating for every future GPT-5.x family.

Reported-by: Tech Solution (@techsolutionmta) (https://github.com/decolua/9router/issues/2540)
2026-07-17 10:43:37 -03:00

157 lines
6.5 KiB
TypeScript

/**
* GPT-5 sampling guard for the OpenAI Chat Completions surface.
*
* The GPT-5 reasoning family rejects non-default sampling params with HTTP 400
* ("Unsupported value: temperature/top_p") WHENEVER a reasoning effort is active —
* but, unlike the o-series, GPT-5.1+ also exposes a non-reasoning mode
* (`reasoning_effort:"none"`, which is the GPT-5.1+ default) under which sampling
* is accepted again. So a static `unsupportedParams` strip (the o3 approach) would
* over-strip the legitimate `effort=none` case, while passing everything through
* leaves `temperature`/`top_p` + active effort exposed to a 400.
*
* This guard removes `temperature`/`top_p` only when the resolved effort is active
* (anything other than `none`). It is scoped to the `openai` provider (raw
* api.openai.com Chat Completions): the `codex` provider's Responses requests are
* already covered by the CodexExecutor allowlist (which drops both params), and
* other providers manage their own sampling rules.
*
* Refs: litellm#27351 (GPT-5.1 accepts temperature only when effort=none),
* Azure Foundry reasoning matrix, openai-python#2072.
*/
import { FORMATS } from "../translator/formats.ts";
type JsonRecord = Record<string, unknown>;
const SAMPLING_PARAMS = ["temperature", "top_p"] as const;
// Suffix that encodes an active (non-none) reasoning effort, e.g. `gpt-5.4-high`.
const ACTIVE_EFFORT_SUFFIX = /-(low|medium|high|xhigh|minimal)$/i;
// Suffix that encodes the explicit non-reasoning mode, e.g. `gpt-5.4-none`.
const NONE_EFFORT_SUFFIX = /-none$/i;
function asRecord(value: unknown): JsonRecord | null {
return value && typeof value === "object" && !Array.isArray(value) ? (value as JsonRecord) : null;
}
/**
* True when the request carries an active reasoning effort (any level other than
* `none`). When there is no signal at all we return false: GPT-5.1+ defaults to
* `none`, so the safe assumption is "reasoning off → sampling allowed".
*/
function hasActiveReasoning(record: JsonRecord, model: string): boolean {
const effort = record.reasoning_effort;
if (typeof effort === "string") return effort.toLowerCase() !== "none";
const reasoning = asRecord(record.reasoning);
if (reasoning && typeof reasoning.effort === "string") {
return reasoning.effort.toLowerCase() !== "none";
}
if (NONE_EFFORT_SUFFIX.test(model)) return false;
if (ACTIVE_EFFORT_SUFFIX.test(model)) return true;
return false;
}
export function stripGpt5SamplingWhenReasoning<T extends Record<string, unknown>>(
body: T,
provider: string | null | undefined,
model: string | null | undefined,
log?: { warn?: (tag: string, message: string) => void } | null
): T {
if (provider !== "openai") return body;
if (typeof model !== "string" || !/^gpt-5/i.test(model)) return body;
const record = asRecord(body);
if (!record) return body;
if (!hasActiveReasoning(record, model)) return body;
const stripped: string[] = [];
for (const param of SAMPLING_PARAMS) {
if (Object.hasOwn(record, param)) stripped.push(param);
}
if (stripped.length === 0) return body;
const next: JsonRecord = { ...record };
for (const param of stripped) delete next[param];
log?.warn?.(
"PARAMS",
`Stripped ${stripped.join(", ")} for reasoning-active ${model} ` +
`(GPT-5 rejects sampling params unless reasoning_effort=none)`
);
return next as T;
}
const REASONING_FIELDS = ["reasoning_effort", "reasoning"] as const;
/**
* True when the request carries a non-empty `tools` array holding at least one
* function-shaped tool entry (`{type:"function", ...}` or a bare `{name, ...}`
* without a `type`, the OpenAI Chat Completions convention).
*/
function hasFunctionTools(record: JsonRecord): boolean {
if (!Array.isArray(record.tools) || record.tools.length === 0) return false;
return record.tools.some((toolValue) => {
const tool = asRecord(toolValue);
if (!tool) return false;
const toolType = typeof tool.type === "string" ? tool.type : "";
return toolType === "" || toolType === "function";
});
}
/**
* Raw api.openai.com Chat Completions rejects GPT-5.x reasoning models that
* carry BOTH function `tools` and an active `reasoning_effort` with HTTP 400:
* "Function tools with reasoning_effort are not supported for <model> in
* /v1/chat/completions. Please use /v1/responses instead." Historically the
* plain `openai` provider always stayed on `/chat/completions` for every
* GPT-5.x model, so this combination reached the upstream 400 with no way to
* recover other than dropping the reasoning fields.
*
* That is no longer true for every GPT-5.x model: the public GPT-5.6 family
* is tagged with `targetFormat: "openai-responses"` (see
* `GPT_5_6_API_CAPABILITIES` in `config/providers/shared.ts`, closes #2540 /
* 9router#2547) and is routed to `/v1/responses` instead, which natively
* accepts tools + reasoning together — /v1/responses is literally the
* endpoint the 400 message tells callers to use. Gate on the resolved
* `targetFormat` (the fact chatCore already computed for this request)
* rather than a model-name list: only strip when the request is actually
* going out over `/chat/completions`. If a future GPT-5.x family also moves
* to `/responses`, this guard keeps working with no change needed here.
* Port of 9router#2540.
*/
export function stripGpt5ReasoningWhenTools<T extends Record<string, unknown>>(
body: T,
provider: string | null | undefined,
model: string | null | undefined,
targetFormat: string | null | undefined,
log?: { warn?: (tag: string, message: string) => void } | null
): T {
if (provider !== "openai") return body;
if (typeof model !== "string" || !/^gpt-5/i.test(model)) return body;
// Already routed to /v1/responses (e.g. GPT-5.6, #7242) — that endpoint
// supports tools + reasoning natively, nothing to strip.
if (targetFormat === FORMATS.OPENAI_RESPONSES) return body;
const record = asRecord(body);
if (!record) return body;
if (!hasFunctionTools(record)) return body;
if (!hasActiveReasoning(record, model)) return body;
const stripped: string[] = [];
for (const field of REASONING_FIELDS) {
if (Object.hasOwn(record, field)) stripped.push(field);
}
if (stripped.length === 0) return body;
const next: JsonRecord = { ...record };
for (const field of stripped) delete next[field];
log?.warn?.(
"PARAMS",
`Stripped ${stripped.join(", ")} for ${model} (function tools + reasoning_effort ` +
`are rejected on /v1/chat/completions; use /v1/responses instead)`
);
return next as T;
}